Knowing when to replace or repair your driveway can save you both time and money in the long run. At Beau-tar Construction, we’ve seen countless Somerset homeowners struggle with this decision. Should you patch up those cracks one more time, or is it time for a complete overhaul? Today, we’ll walk you through the tell-tale signs that your driveway has reached the point of no return and needs replacing rather than another quick fix.
1. Multiple Large Cracks
Small, hairline cracks can often be repaired, but when your driveway resembles a spider’s web of interconnected cracks, it’s usually a sign of deeper structural issues. These extensive crack networks allow water to penetrate beneath your driveway, accelerating deterioration, especially during our wet Somerset winters.
If your driveway has multiple cracks larger than 1/4 inch wide or cracks that have widened over time despite previous repairs, it’s likely time for a full replacement.
2. Significant Drainage Problems
Does your driveway turn into a paddling pool every time it rains? Poor drainage doesn’t just create inconvenience—it causes serious damage to your driveway’s foundation. Water that pools on or around your driveway will eventually find its way underneath, causing the base materials to wash away and create voids that lead to sinking and cracking.
If you’ve already tried drainage solutions without success, your driveway likely needs a complete rebuild with proper gradients and possibly drainage systems.
3. Multiple Potholes
A single small pothole might be repairable, but when your driveway starts resembling the lunar surface, patchwork repairs won’t hold up. Potholes form when the base layer of your driveway has been compromised, meaning the problem extends far below what you can see.
On most driveways in Taunton and surrounding areas we’ve replaced due to potholes had underlying drainage or base issues that patchwork couldn’t solve.
4. Surface Deterioration Over 25% of the Area
If more than a quarter of your driveway shows signs of ravelling (loose material on the surface), crumbling edges, or severe fading and oil stains that won’t clean up, repairs will end up looking patchy and uneven.
Our experience installing driveways in Bridgwater has shown that once deterioration reaches this level, a new driveway becomes more cost-effective than ongoing repairs.
5. Age Beyond Expected Lifespan
Even the best-maintained driveways have a finite lifespan:
- Tarmac/asphalt: 15-20 years
- Concrete: 25-30 years
- Block paving: 20-25 years (if properly maintained)
If your driveway is approaching or has exceeded these timeframes, recurring repairs are throwing good money after bad. Modern materials and installation techniques used in our Weston-Super-Mare driveway projects offer significant improvements in durability and appearance over older installations.
6. Sinking or Dipping Areas
Uneven sections where your driveway has sunk or formed dips indicate serious problems with the foundation. These depressions collect water, accelerating damage and potentially leading to issues with your home’s foundation if located near the property.
We’ve seen this frequently when installing driveways in Yeovil and across Somerset—once significant dipping occurs, full replacement with proper base preparation is the only lasting solution.
7. Kerb Appeal and Property Value Concerns
Sometimes the decision to replace rather than repair comes down to appearances. If your driveway detracts from your home’s kerb appeal despite repairs, it’s affecting your property’s value.
Our gallery shows the dramatic difference a new driveway makes to a property’s overall impression. Many clients in Wells and Ilminster have reported increased property valuations after driveway replacements.
Making the Right Choice for Your Property
While repairs might seem like the budget-friendly option initially, they often end up costing more over time if your driveway is truly at the end of its service life. Continuing to repair a driveway that’s beyond salvation is like putting a plaster on a broken arm—it might cover the problem, but it won’t fix it.
At Beau-tar Construction, we specialise in helping Somerset homeowners determine whether to replace or repair driveways based on honest assessments. We’re proud to be approved installers of Marshalls products, ensuring your new driveway isn’t just a quick fix but a lasting investment in your property.
Ready for Expert Advice?
If you’re noticing any of these signs, it might be time for a new driveway installation. Our experienced hardscapers at Beau-tar Construction provide free consultations to help you make an informed decision. Whether you need a simple repair or complete driveway installation, we’ll give you straightforward advice without the hard sell.
Based in Burrowbridge, Bridgwater, we serve Taunton, Bridgwater, Weston-Super-Mare, Wellington, Glastonbury and all surrounding areas across Somerset. Don’t wait until minor problems become major headaches – contact us today on 01823 690 229 to arrange a site visit and quote.
Check out our guide on choosing the right paving material to start exploring your options for a driveway that will stand the test of time in our British climate.